The “forest fungi are just like our conception of the internet/kinship/brains/etc.” story is a fun one and I suspect it’ll be around for a long time. But I think this piece is a good model for one way to shoo back an overextended idea.
https://undark.org/2023/05/25/where-the-wood-wide-web-narrative-went-wrong/
I think there’s a powerful force in popular science writing, more or less necessary to what we’d recognize as popular science writing at all, to familiarize the strange. This is not formally divisible from what it means to explain something.
But metaphors are always not good enough or too good. There’s never the one that takes you exactly as far as it’s accurate and leaves you hydrated, sunscreened, and pointed in the right direction.
A wrinkle in the “forests are internets” thing is that (I suspect) a lot of people promulgating it are trying to do forests a favor by putting them in these terms. In practice, this may often be true. But it seems worth watching closely. These things get away from us.
Things we aren’t – forests or LLMs or planets or abacuses or moths or whatever – aren’t us in domino masks. It is not the case that everything other than the human soul is only present in creation in order to provide metaphors to humans for their souls. I also suspect that Italian is not just English with a really strong Italian accent and bees are not a model for a perfect human society. Different things are actually different.
@vruba circling back to the moth thing: ok but are you sure
@robinsonmeyer @urschrei Oh great, heckles from the mystics.
@robinsonmeyer @vruba @urschrei *inaudibly screaming in moth bark shots*
@vruba @robinsonmeyer @urschrei perfect sentence, charlie
@meetar @robinsonmeyer @urschrei Alan Watts’s most lyrical essay collection, imho.
@vruba moth dahnces
@robinsonmeyer @urschrei (To take this more seriously: I do firmly believe there’s a way in which moths are in fact us in domino masks after all. The problem is that if you have that sense but not the sense that you’re equally a moth in a domino mask, I think you have a hierarchical view of the universe that sounds communal, and that’s dangerous.)